Review website Yelp to name and shame fake online restaurant reviewers

By Joe Lutrario

- Last updated on GMT

Restaurants posting fake positive reviews about themselves online or negative posts on competitors may now face being named and shamed
Restaurants posting fake positive reviews about themselves online or negative posts on competitors may now face being named and shamed
Restaurateurs that post positive fake reviews about their own venues or negative fake reviews about competitors are being warned that the major review sites are looking to clamp down hard on the practice with Yelp leading the way.

The major user review and local search website is already naming and shaming businesses. Those that get caught will have to suffer the embarrassment of having a red warning label placed across their Yelp listing.

"We caught someone red-handed trying to buy reviews for their business. We weren’t fooled, but wanted you to know because buying reviews not only hurts consumers, but also honest businesses who play by the rules,” the Yelp box reads, before linking to the bogus reviews in question.

Baiting businesses

Yelp vice-president Eric Singley says the alert will be removed from the business’s page after 90 days, unless evidence of on-going malpractice is discovered. “We think consumers have a right to know when someone is going to great lengths to mislead them,” he adds.

While policing the millions of comments posted on review sites may seem a gargantuan task, advances in technology are allowing companies to develop complex filters and algorithms that weed out fakes. It is also understood that some sites are even considering baiting businesses with ‘would you like to buy positive reviews’ solicitations.


The review sites are responding to significant pressure from businesses to get their houses in order. TripAdvisor was recently the subject of a Channel 4 documentary​ that revealed how easy it was to post large numbers of fake reviews.

The programme’s findings were backed up by hospitality consultancy Visionary Dining, which exposed various flaws in TripAdvisor’s security system – it was able to post multiple reviews by downloading an IP address changer and setting up multiple email accounts.

TripAdvisor has since defended its policies, saying that it has robust fraud detection systems.

“Until recently it has been too easy for opportunistic businesses to enhance their online reputation,” says Mark Hall, managing director at Gotjuice, an online reputation management consultancy. “That ride, however, is now over and we welcome the naming and shaming of those that abuse the system. It’s a form of fraud and it can seriously damage other hard-working businesses.”

Malicious customers

Another common gripe from restaurateurs regarding review sites is malicious, inaccurate or false posts from customers. 

Currently, there is little a restaurant can do to remove critical posts unless they are libellous (for example those that accuse an operation of serious hygiene breaches or employing staff illegally) although some sites do offer restaurant owners the right of reply.

One strategy – that has been suggested by Visionary Dining managing director Gordon Cartwright – is to put cards on the table politely requesting that customers put till receipt numbers at the end of reviews.

Related news

Show more

1 comment

Get to know your customers & talk to them directly

Posted by Natalie - HospitalityGEM,

It's important that customers feel that their comments are valid and not ignored. If business owners abuse third party sites they won't get the feedback and recommendations they want.

We fully support the crack down on fake reviews and understand the importance in building communication and trust with customers. For businesses the array of review sites to monitor can be a tough and laborious task. We recommend hosting a fully branded online feedback site so that the business can then monitor their own online reputation and respond in a quick and easy way.

Good to see this taking place on Yelp, but it needs to happen everywhere.

Report abuse



Follow us

Hospitality Guides

View more

Featured Suppliers

All suppliers